动产抵押制度之矛盾考察

Contradiction Investigation of Chattel Mortgage System

  • 摘要: 我国物权法规定了动产抵押制度,并采公示(登记)对抗主义。动产抵押制度突破了传统民法对典型担保的设计,因而在理论上产生了许多难以克服的障碍,公示对抗主义则直接导致同一物上物权的冲突与对抗,因此造成物权法中出现了结构性矛盾。将动产抵押制度纳入到物权法典中仍值得商榷,在今后的民法典编纂中应结合相关制度(如让与担保制度)的考察对该制度之取舍进行慎重考虑。

     

    Abstract: Property Law of China states the chattel mortgage system and adopts notification (registration) antagonism. Since the chattel mortgage system breaks the designs of traditional civil law to typical guarantee, a lot of formidable obstacles come into being theoretically. The notification antagonism directly results in conflict and antagonism of the property rights on the same property, which gives rise to constitutive contradiction in Property Law of China. It is open to discussion on bringing chattel mortgage system into line with Property Law, and during the future compilation of civil law, it shall be contemplated whether to accept or reject the system with the combination of investigation into relevant systems ( such as alienation guarantee system).

     

/

返回文章
返回