蔡潇, 刘从德. 爱德华·卡尔对马克思主义国际关系学说的误读[J]. 电子科技大学学报社科版, 2016, 18(5): 89-95. DOI: 10.14071/j.1008-8105(2016)05-0089-07
引用本文: 蔡潇, 刘从德. 爱德华·卡尔对马克思主义国际关系学说的误读[J]. 电子科技大学学报社科版, 2016, 18(5): 89-95. DOI: 10.14071/j.1008-8105(2016)05-0089-07
CAI Xiao, LIU Cong-de. E.H. Carr's Viewpoints on International Relations of Marxism[J]. Journal of University of Electronic Science and Technology of China(SOCIAL SCIENCES EDITION), 2016, 18(5): 89-95. DOI: 10.14071/j.1008-8105(2016)05-0089-07
Citation: CAI Xiao, LIU Cong-de. E.H. Carr's Viewpoints on International Relations of Marxism[J]. Journal of University of Electronic Science and Technology of China(SOCIAL SCIENCES EDITION), 2016, 18(5): 89-95. DOI: 10.14071/j.1008-8105(2016)05-0089-07

爱德华·卡尔对马克思主义国际关系学说的误读

E.H. Carr's Viewpoints on International Relations of Marxism

  • 摘要: 在当前的国际关系研究中,现实主义、自由主义等西方社会思潮占据主导地位,把握了话语权,马克思主义国际关系理论处于边缘化位置。爱德华·卡尔是国际关系现实主义流派创始人,其代表作《20年危机(1919~1939)国际关系研究导论》是国际关系现实主义流派经典著作。在卡尔批判两次世界大战之间国际关系领域中弥漫着的理想主义风潮时,引证了诸多马克思主义的观点,存在着不少误读。卡尔从传统政治学的现实主义脉络出发,认为经济力量实际上就是政治力量来模糊经济基础与上层建筑决定与被决定关系、以“阶级利益和谐”论来取代马克思的阶级斗争理论、认为马克思是简单物化了黑格尔的观念冲突、从研究愿望与研究过程的区别来拆解马克思主义、用对法律相对性评价的一致性模糊现实主义的最终目的是回归资本主义体系、对俄国革命、苏联政策进行意识形态简单区分来否定马克思主义。

     

    Abstract: E.H. Carr is the founding father of realism in international relations, and his magnum opus-The 20 Year's Crisis (1919~1939): An Introduction to the Study of International Relations-is a classic masterpiece of realism in international relations, in which the author E. H. Carr applied the viewpoints of Marxism to criticizing the idealism in international relations during the two world wars. E.H. Carr's research began with the realism in traditional politics, and he then analyzed Marxism in the light of the differences between research objective and research process and replaced Marx's theory of class struggle with ‘harmony of class interest’. He thought that Marx simply materialized Hegel's concept conflict, insisting that economic force was actually using political force to confuse the relationship of the two as deciding factor or being decided, using the consistency of relative evaluation on law to confuse the fact that the ultimate purpose of realism was to return to capitalist system and distinguishing Russian Revolution and Soviet policies by ideology to negate Marxism.

     

/

返回文章
返回