梁娟, 王丽丽, 蔡猷花. 科技服务业集群城市创新绩效多元提升路径研究—基于fsQCA方法[J]. 电子科技大学学报(社科版), 2024, 26(1): 75-84.. DOI: 10.14071/j.1008-8105(2023)-5012
引用本文: 梁娟, 王丽丽, 蔡猷花. 科技服务业集群城市创新绩效多元提升路径研究—基于fsQCA方法[J]. 电子科技大学学报(社科版), 2024, 26(1): 75-84.. DOI: 10.14071/j.1008-8105(2023)-5012
LIANG Juan, WANG Li-li, CAI You-hua. Research on Multiple Promotion Paths of Science and Technology Service Industry Cluster Cities’ Innovation Performance Based on fsQCA[J]. Journal of University of Electronic Science and Technology of China(SOCIAL SCIENCES EDITION), 2024, 26(1): 75-84. DOI: 10.14071/j.1008-8105(2023)-5012
Citation: LIANG Juan, WANG Li-li, CAI You-hua. Research on Multiple Promotion Paths of Science and Technology Service Industry Cluster Cities’ Innovation Performance Based on fsQCA[J]. Journal of University of Electronic Science and Technology of China(SOCIAL SCIENCES EDITION), 2024, 26(1): 75-84. DOI: 10.14071/j.1008-8105(2023)-5012

科技服务业集群城市创新绩效多元提升路径研究基于fsQCA方法

Research on Multiple Promotion Paths of Science and Technology Service Industry Cluster Cities’ Innovation Performance Based on fsQCA

  • 摘要: 科技服务业集群城市是创新网络中促进创新流动的关键节点和重要组成部分。在实践中,嵌入相同网络的城市会产生差异化的创新绩效。创新网络如何影响这些差异,以及创新网络嵌入和内生创新努力如何相互作用影响城市创新绩效,需要进一步分析。基于组态视角,以中国 23个科技服务业集群城市为案例,运用fsQCA方法,从外因和内因两个维度,探讨多层次创新网络嵌入、内生创新努力的协同效应及其影响城市创新绩效的多重并发因果关系与多元路径。结果表明:(1)多层次创新网络嵌入、内生创新努力与创新绩效之间存在多重并发因果关系,单个条件不足以激发高创新绩效,需要多条件联动发挥组合效应;(2)高创新绩效的组态有4个,可归纳为关系—人员驱动型和结构—经费驱动型两条提升路径,有12个案例,多为北京、上海、广州等一线城市;(3)非高创新绩效的组态有两个,归纳为关系—经费抑制型和关系—结构抑制型2种构型,具有强隶属度的案例多为东北和中西部的城市。研究结论克服已有单层面因果关系研究的缺陷,从“因果不对称”的角度,找到了影响集群城市高创新绩效的等效驱动路径,并讨论了高创新绩效抑制路径,拓宽了QCA方法的应用范围。

     

    Abstract: Science and technology service industry cluster cities are important components and key nodes of innovation networks driving the flow and configuration of innovation. In practice, cities embedded in the same network have differentiated innovation performance owing to differing research and development (R&D) investment and personnel. Therefore, how innovation networks affect these differences, and how innovation network embedding and endogenous innovation efforts interact to affect cities’ innovation performance, requires further analysis. From the perspective of configuration, using the QCA method, this study presents structural and relational embeddedness, R&D funds, and R&D personnel into the same analytical framework using the two levels of network embeddedness and endogenous innovation efforts. The cases come from 23 science and technology service cluster cities in China. The results indicate that: (1) there are multiple concurrent causal relationships among multi-level innovation network embeddedness, endogenous innovation efforts, and innovation performance. A single condition is not enough to stimulate high innovation performance, and multiple conditions must be linked to have a combined effect. (2) There are four configurations to high innovation performance, which can be summarized into two paths: realtionship-personnel drivern and structural-fund driven. The research finds 12 cases, most of which pertain to eastern cities such as Beijing, Shanghai and Guangzhou. (3) There are two paths leading to low innovation performance, which can be summarized into two configurations: relationship-fund inhibited and structural-relationship inhibited. The results show most of which pertain to cities mostly in the Northeast and Midwest. They overcome the shortcomings of the existing single-level causality research, explain the “embeddedness paradox” in the network embeddedness theory, and help reveal the causal mechanism driving cities’ high innovation performance. From the perspective of “causal asymmetry”, this paper finds the equivalent driving path affecting high innovation performance of these cluster cities, and discusses the inhibition path of high innovation performance which broadens application of the QCA method.

     

/

返回文章
返回