国际商事仲裁视阈下人工智能辅助仲裁的困境与中国对策

The Predicament of AI-Assisted Arbitration from the Perspective of International Commercial Arbitration and the Countermeasures of China

  • 摘要: 人工智能在国际商事仲裁中的应用日益增多,正确认识和妥善应对国际商事仲裁视阈下人工智能辅助仲裁所面临的困境,是关系着仲裁智能化进程推进速度的核心问题。国际商事仲裁视阈下,人工智能辅助仲裁需要面临功能困境、信任困境与执行困境。第一,由于人工智能功能的实现与优化高度依赖大体量的数据,数据跨境流动的壁垒导致仲裁裁决数据获取受限,引发了功能困境;第二,由于仲裁当事方对仲裁中所应用的人工智能的信任建立在算法运行透明的基础上,当前算法监管机制无法有效满足当事方对透明度的高需求,削弱了人工智能的可信度;第三,由于仲裁程序本质上属于私程序,当仲裁裁决的执行需要借助国家强制力时,由法院进行司法审查并作出最终判定,而现有司法审查规则的滞后性一定程度上减损了仲裁裁决的可执行性。鉴于推动仲裁智能化发展的迫切需求,应以数据治理策略、完善算法监管机制和更新仲裁监督规则为破解困境的中国对策。

     

    Abstract: The application of artificial intelligence arbitration in international commercial arbitration is on the rise, properly recognizing and appropriately addressing the the predicament of AI-assisted arbitration from the perspective of international commercial arbitration is a core issue that affects the speed of the arbitration intelligentization process. AI-assisted arbitration in international commercial arbitration faces functional dilemmas, trust dilemmas and implementation dilemmas. First, as the realization and optimization of AI functions are highly dependent on a large volume of data, the barriers to cross-border flow of data lead to restricted access to data for arbitration awards, triggering functional dilemmas; second, as the trust of arbitration parties in AI arbitration is built on the basis of transparency of algorithmic operation, the current algorithmic regulatory mechanism is unable to effectively satisfy the high demand of parties for transparency, weakening the the credibility of AI; third, as the Arbitration procedure is essentially a private procedure, when the enforcement of the arbitral award needs to rely on state coercion, the court will conduct a judicial review and make a final decision, and the lag of the existing judicial review rules to a certain extent detracts from the enforceability of the arbitral award. In view of the urgent need to promote the intelligent development of arbitration, the specific paths to overcome the predicaments should be to adopt data governance strategies, improve the algorithm regulatory mechanism and update the arbitration supervision rules.

     

/

返回文章
返回